Egregoros

Signal feed

Timeline

Post

Remote status

I worry that some people aren’t taking Omarchy seriously enough. It’s not just another Linux distro. It’s a well-orchestrated campaign to centralize power and influence within the Linux FOSS ecosystem. And it’s working.

Anyone paying attention to DHH and what he stands for can see what’s going on here. When the guy who thinks that brown people don’t belong in society hires the guy who thinks trans people shouldn’t exist, you can see where this is going.

Replies

25
@neatnik it seems to be an annual truth that some people value the specific moral character and ideology of the people who make a thing (to varying levels of quality-detriment) while others care about the quality of a product and ignore the character of the person who has made the thing, and that these two groups keep forgetting about each other and being shocked to learn there are people who are not like them

maybe it's just the churn of young people learning the lesson because they were never introduced to it in formal education or childhood
@binkle @neatnik caring about the values of the people who make things that i use seem exhausting. i imagine i'd end up with dysfunctional shit software if j went that route. tbh i don't know about the values of the developers of 99% of the software that i use and i don't want to know and don't want to care.

for example i use kitty, i don't know the dev, don't know about their values, don't want to know. it is good software and that is enough for me.
@neatnik Make a better product. Just from looking at the incoming flow of money, it seems that there's lots of interest in what DHH is doing. No wonder investors are throwing money at a guy that wants to drop half of the desktop Linux foundation, when the rest is stuck bikeshedding in Wayland issues about how a protocol telling compositors about round window edges or screen positioning should work.
@phnt @neatnik institutional capture is a very interesting topic to me because it always happens and it always goes the same way. The linux community as is has largely become a nepotistic circle jerk only interested in maintaining their own fiefdoms

I have to give it to them, "post-meritocracy" is a brilliant way to reframe cronyism.
@KaiserKitty @neatnik I have no opinion on it yet because I haven't tried it. What I do know is I cannot take the word of linux enthusiasts. I can count on one hand the number of times they've told me correct information about the ecosystem

their platforms do not work despite decades of them insisting they do and I'm just doing it wrong
@RustyCrab @neatnik just look at how it actually works and you can see how stupid this is. People only defend because they are a brand new to Linux Redditor who wowed by fancy ricing.

Omarchy is doing nothing special. Its auto arch install is just like existing ones. You can configure hpyrland yourself. DHH has just automated all of this with fragile shell scripts. There is no special sauce here it’s just simplifying the easy stuff at the cost of having a very opinionated default which is hard to customize. I just personally avoid these one man custom rice distros. Same reason I tell people not to use nobara, you are begging to get screwed when they start making their own opinionated changes.

I think finding a guys shells scripts over the actual packages he’s taking from is retarded and reveals this all as a dumb vanity project.
@RustyCrab @neatnik
When the community in the movement is almost divided in half about the issues of copyright/intellectual property (a dumb concept) and/or the usage of any AI, it benefits those that want the movement to die. So in a way, by being mad online about some free/open source project using LLMs, those that are angry are helping the other side trying to destroy their movement they are fighting for. How?

When everybody is preoccupied with endless and usually absolutely meaningless arguments ad infinitum, nothing productive ever gets done. The community is divided, contributors and maintainers from both sides now don't get along, forks that didn't need to exist happen and actual progress on writing good software stalls to a halt.

The movement dies.
- My blog post :)