Egregoros

Signal feed

Timeline

Post

Remote status

Context

4
China Professor just dropped a new video...

* No regime change has ever been achieved by air power alone

* Iran's goal is to destroy critical infrastructure all across the Gulf, b/c stopping the flow of oil stops the flow of Saudi investment into the US

* The US economy is a ponzi scheme which survives on Saudi investment (this makes a lot of sense, because as bad as the real economy is, the stock market always manages to have money)

* One choke-point is water, because it all comes from a handful of centralized desalination plants (terrifying)

* "Shock and awe" only works against enemies who fight like Saddam Hussein, if your enemies fight like the Taliban, it's utterly useless

* Missile interceptors are orders of magnitude more expensive than the missiles themselves, and you need to fire multiple to have a good chance of hitting one missile

* Even if the war is not good for America, it may still be good for Trump personally

* Powerful end-times fanatics will push for war, even if totally irrational, because they're trying to fulfill prophecy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXe9DZdTbGM
If Saudi (and other gulf) money is really what's holding up the US economy, then when that stops, ye ol' AI bubble is gonna get hammered.

But it's hard to really bet on it because there's two possible ways it can go:
1. Asset prices in USD go down
2. Asset prices maintain or rise, but USD is devalued

No way to know which way it will be...

@cjd
The Saudi's agreed to a RECORD investment into the US this year of 1 Trillion dollars. This is 25x their usual rate and only amounts to 3% of GDP and .07% of the wealth in the US and less than 20% of all foreign investment.
It is hard to believe that this is holding up the US economy

I still find it plausible because GDP is such a misleading number.

You know the famous comic with two economists paying each other to eat shit and then saying they've increased GDP and created 2 jobs...

At the beginning of the Ukraine war, it was famously quipped that Russia has a smaller economy than Italy. But I don't think Italy would have managed to do what Russia has done - so clearly energy export GDP is worth more than "service economy GDP", or (heaven forbid) regulatory GDP...

@cjd
It's true that GDP is a poor measure overall, it still has some value for comparison. Here is another; Total capital expenditures in the US Just for 3rd Quarter in 2025 were 8.6 Trillion. And over time, the Saudi FDI into the US is still a relatively small percentage of the total FDI into the US.

The US economy is huge and 22x the size of the Saudi Economy. No matter what comparisons one uses, it seems a stretch.

Replies

11
The US economy IS big, but I think it's mostly small businesses, and of course they don't get any Saudi money, the only thing they see is a tax bill.

But I wouldn't be surprised if rugpulling Saudi money would cause the AI bubble to vaporize, and probably take a bunch of Wall St. banks with it.

Right but what I mean is if Japan has 10 trillion in US investments, that doesn't tell you if they sent 10 trillion last year, or if they sent it 20 years ago and last year they sent nothing. Hence why I say investment growth is going to be the more telling number...